Android MediaRecorder系统结构

前面有分析过Camera的实现，现在来看看MediaRecorder的实现，这里我不会太去关注它的分层结构，我更关注它的逻辑！

APP层 /path/to/aosp/frameworks/base/media/java/android/media/MediaRecorder.java
JNI层 /path/to/aosp/frameworks/base/media/jni/android_media_MediaRecorder.cpp
调用NATIVE层的MediaRecorder(这里是BnMediaRecorderClient)
header /path/to/aosp/frameworks/av/include/media/mediarecorder.h
implementation /path/to/aosp/frameworks/av/media/libmedia/mediarecorder.cpp

MediaRecorder::MediaRecorder() : mSurfaceMediaSource(NULL)
{
    ALOGV("constructor");

    const sp<IMediaPlayerService>& service(getMediaPlayerService());
    if (service != NULL) {
        mMediaRecorder = service->createMediaRecorder(getpid());
    }
    if (mMediaRecorder != NULL) {
        mCurrentState = MEDIA_RECORDER_IDLE;
    }

    doCleanUp();
}

getMediaPlayerService()这个方法位于/path/to/aosp/frameworks/av/include/media/IMediaDeathNotifier.h

获取到MediaPlayerService(这个是BpMediaPlayerService)之后
调用IMediaPlayerService当中的

sp<IMediaRecorder> MediaPlayerService::createMediaRecorder(pid_t pid)
{
    sp<MediaRecorderClient> recorder = new MediaRecorderClient(this, pid);
    wp<MediaRecorderClient> w = recorder;
    Mutex::Autolock lock(mLock);
    mMediaRecorderClients.add(w);
    ALOGV("Create new media recorder client from pid %d", pid);
    return recorder;
}

创建MediaRecorderClient(这里是BnMediaRecorder)

但是通过binder拿到的是BpMediaRecorder
因为有如下的interface_cast过程

virtual sp<IMediaRecorder> createMediaRecorder(pid_t pid)
{
    Parcel data, reply;
    data.writeInterfaceToken(IMediaPlayerService::getInterfaceDescriptor());
    data.writeInt32(pid);
    remote()->transact(CREATE_MEDIA_RECORDER, data, &reply);
    return interface_cast<IMediaRecorder>(reply.readStrongBinder());
}

而MediaRecorderClient当中又会创建StagefrightRecorder(MediaRecorderBase)，它位于
/path/to/aosp/frameworks/av/media/libmediaplayerservice/StagefrightRecorder.cpp

目前我们可以认为在APP/JNI/NATIVE这边是在一个进程当中，在MediaPlayerService当中的MediaRecorderClient/StagefrightRecorder是在另外一个进程当中，他们之间通过binder通信，而且Bp和Bn我们也都有拿到，后面我们将不再仔细区分Bp和Bn。

客户端这边
BnMediaRecorderClient
BpMediaRecorder
BpMediaPlayerService

服务端这边
BpMediaRecorderClient(如果需要通知客户端的话，它可以获得这个Bp)
BnMediaRecorder
BnMediaPlayerService

这有张图(点过去看原始大图)

我们以开始录影为例子，比如start()

在这里就兵分两路，一个CameraSource，一个MPEG4Writer(sp mWriter)
这两个class都位于/path/to/aosp/frameworks/av/media/libstagefright/当中

status_t StagefrightRecorder::startMPEG4Recording() {
    int32_t totalBitRate;
    status_t err = setupMPEG4Recording(
            mOutputFd, mVideoWidth, mVideoHeight,
            mVideoBitRate, &totalBitRate, &mWriter);
    if (err != OK) {
        return err;
    }

    int64_t startTimeUs = systemTime() / 1000;
    sp<MetaData> meta = new MetaData;
    setupMPEG4MetaData(startTimeUs, totalBitRate, &meta);

    err = mWriter->start(meta.get());
    if (err != OK) {
        return err;
    }

    return OK;
}

status_t StagefrightRecorder::setupMPEG4Recording(
        int outputFd,
        int32_t videoWidth, int32_t videoHeight,
        int32_t videoBitRate,
        int32_t *totalBitRate,
        sp<MediaWriter> *mediaWriter) {
    mediaWriter->clear();
    *totalBitRate = 0;
    status_t err = OK;
    sp<MediaWriter> writer = new MPEG4Writer(outputFd);

    if (mVideoSource < VIDEO_SOURCE_LIST_END) {

        sp<MediaSource> mediaSource;
        err = setupMediaSource(&mediaSource); // very important
        if (err != OK) {
            return err;
        }

        sp<MediaSource> encoder;
        err = setupVideoEncoder(mediaSource, videoBitRate, &encoder); // very important
        if (err != OK) {
            return err;
        }

        writer->addSource(encoder);
        *totalBitRate += videoBitRate;
    }

    // Audio source is added at the end if it exists.
    // This help make sure that the "recoding" sound is suppressed for
    // camcorder applications in the recorded files.
    if (!mCaptureTimeLapse && (mAudioSource != AUDIO_SOURCE_CNT)) {
        err = setupAudioEncoder(writer); // very important
        if (err != OK) return err;
        *totalBitRate += mAudioBitRate;
    }

    ...

    writer->setListener(mListener);
    *mediaWriter = writer;
    return OK;
}

// Set up the appropriate MediaSource depending on the chosen option
status_t StagefrightRecorder::setupMediaSource(
                      sp<MediaSource> *mediaSource) {
    if (mVideoSource == VIDEO_SOURCE_DEFAULT
            || mVideoSource == VIDEO_SOURCE_CAMERA) {
        sp<CameraSource> cameraSource;
        status_t err = setupCameraSource(&cameraSource);
        if (err != OK) {
            return err;
        }
        *mediaSource = cameraSource;
    } else if (mVideoSource == VIDEO_SOURCE_GRALLOC_BUFFER) {
        // If using GRAlloc buffers, setup surfacemediasource.
        // Later a handle to that will be passed
        // to the client side when queried
        status_t err = setupSurfaceMediaSource();
        if (err != OK) {
            return err;
        }
        *mediaSource = mSurfaceMediaSource;
    } else {
        return INVALID_OPERATION;
    }
    return OK;
}

status_t StagefrightRecorder::setupCameraSource(
        sp<CameraSource> *cameraSource) {
    status_t err = OK;
    if ((err = checkVideoEncoderCapabilities()) != OK) {
        return err;
    }
    Size videoSize;
    videoSize.width = mVideoWidth;
    videoSize.height = mVideoHeight;
    if (mCaptureTimeLapse) {
        if (mTimeBetweenTimeLapseFrameCaptureUs < 0) {
            ALOGE("Invalid mTimeBetweenTimeLapseFrameCaptureUs value: %lld",
                mTimeBetweenTimeLapseFrameCaptureUs);
            return BAD_VALUE;
        }

        mCameraSourceTimeLapse = CameraSourceTimeLapse::CreateFromCamera(
                mCamera, mCameraProxy, mCameraId,
                videoSize, mFrameRate, mPreviewSurface,
                mTimeBetweenTimeLapseFrameCaptureUs);
        *cameraSource = mCameraSourceTimeLapse;
    } else {
        *cameraSource = CameraSource::CreateFromCamera(
                mCamera, mCameraProxy, mCameraId, videoSize, mFrameRate,
                mPreviewSurface, true /*storeMetaDataInVideoBuffers*/);
    }
    mCamera.clear();
    mCameraProxy.clear();
    if (*cameraSource == NULL) {
        return UNKNOWN_ERROR;
    }

    if ((*cameraSource)->initCheck() != OK) {
        (*cameraSource).clear();
        *cameraSource = NULL;
        return NO_INIT;
    }

    // When frame rate is not set, the actual frame rate will be set to
    // the current frame rate being used.
    if (mFrameRate == -1) {
        int32_t frameRate = 0;
        CHECK ((*cameraSource)->getFormat()->findInt32(
                    kKeyFrameRate, &frameRate));
        ALOGI("Frame rate is not explicitly set. Use the current frame "
             "rate (%d fps)", frameRate);
        mFrameRate = frameRate;
    }

    CHECK(mFrameRate != -1);

    mIsMetaDataStoredInVideoBuffers =
        (*cameraSource)->isMetaDataStoredInVideoBuffers();

    return OK;
}

status_t StagefrightRecorder::setupVideoEncoder(
        sp<MediaSource> cameraSource,
        int32_t videoBitRate,
        sp<MediaSource> *source) {
    source->clear();

    sp<MetaData> enc_meta = new MetaData;
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyBitRate, videoBitRate);
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyFrameRate, mFrameRate);

    switch (mVideoEncoder) {
        case VIDEO_ENCODER_H263:
            enc_meta->setCString(kKeyMIMEType, MEDIA_MIMETYPE_VIDEO_H263);
            break;

        case VIDEO_ENCODER_MPEG_4_SP:
            enc_meta->setCString(kKeyMIMEType, MEDIA_MIMETYPE_VIDEO_MPEG4);
            break;

        case VIDEO_ENCODER_H264:
            enc_meta->setCString(kKeyMIMEType, MEDIA_MIMETYPE_VIDEO_AVC);
            break;

        default:
            CHECK(!"Should not be here, unsupported video encoding.");
            break;
    }

    sp<MetaData> meta = cameraSource->getFormat();

    int32_t width, height, stride, sliceHeight, colorFormat;
    CHECK(meta->findInt32(kKeyWidth, &width));
    CHECK(meta->findInt32(kKeyHeight, &height));
    CHECK(meta->findInt32(kKeyStride, &stride));
    CHECK(meta->findInt32(kKeySliceHeight, &sliceHeight));
    CHECK(meta->findInt32(kKeyColorFormat, &colorFormat));

    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyWidth, width);
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyHeight, height);
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyIFramesInterval, mIFramesIntervalSec);
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyStride, stride);
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeySliceHeight, sliceHeight);
    enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyColorFormat, colorFormat);
    if (mVideoTimeScale > 0) {
        enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyTimeScale, mVideoTimeScale);
    }
    if (mVideoEncoderProfile != -1) {
        enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyVideoProfile, mVideoEncoderProfile);
    }
    if (mVideoEncoderLevel != -1) {
        enc_meta->setInt32(kKeyVideoLevel, mVideoEncoderLevel);
    }

    OMXClient client;
    CHECK_EQ(client.connect(), (status_t)OK);

    uint32_t encoder_flags = 0;
    if (mIsMetaDataStoredInVideoBuffers) {
        encoder_flags |= OMXCodec::kStoreMetaDataInVideoBuffers;
    }

    // Do not wait for all the input buffers to become available.
    // This give timelapse video recording faster response in
    // receiving output from video encoder component.
    if (mCaptureTimeLapse) {
        encoder_flags |= OMXCodec::kOnlySubmitOneInputBufferAtOneTime;
    }

    sp<MediaSource> encoder = OMXCodec::Create(
            client.interface(), enc_meta,
            true /* createEncoder */, cameraSource,
            NULL, encoder_flags);
    if (encoder == NULL) {
        ALOGW("Failed to create the encoder");
        // When the encoder fails to be created, we need
        // release the camera source due to the camera's lock
        // and unlock mechanism.
        cameraSource->stop();
        return UNKNOWN_ERROR;
    }

    *source = encoder;

    return OK;
}

这里和OMXCodec关联起来
有一个叫media_codecs.xml的配置文件来表明设备支持哪些codec

我们录制MPEG 4的时候还会有声音，所以后面还有个setupAudioEncoder，具体的方法就不展开了，总之就是把声音也作为一个Track加入到MPEG4Writer当中去。
这里插个题外话，Google说把setupAudioEncoder放到后面是为了避免开始录影的那一个提示声音也被录制进去，但是实际发现它这样做还是会有bug，在一些设备上还是会把那声录制进去，这个遇到的都是靠APP自己来播放声音来绕过这个问题的。

另外MPEG4Writer当中有个
start(MetaData*)
启动两个方法
a) startWriterThread

启动一个thread去写

    void MPEG4Writer::threadFunc() {
        ALOGV("threadFunc");

        prctl(PR_SET_NAME, (unsigned long)"MPEG4Writer", 0, 0, 0);

        Mutex::Autolock autoLock(mLock);
        while (!mDone) {
            Chunk chunk;
            bool chunkFound = false;

            while (!mDone && !(chunkFound = findChunkToWrite(&chunk))) {
                mChunkReadyCondition.wait(mLock);
            }

            // Actual write without holding the lock in order to
            // reduce the blocking time for media track threads.
            if (chunkFound) {
                mLock.unlock();
                writeChunkToFile(&chunk);
                mLock.lock();
            }
        }

        writeAllChunks();
    }

b) startTracks

    status_t MPEG4Writer::startTracks(MetaData *params) {
        for (List<Track *>::iterator it = mTracks.begin();
             it != mTracks.end(); ++it) {
            status_t err = (*it)->start(params);

            if (err != OK) {
                for (List<Track *>::iterator it2 = mTracks.begin();
                     it2 != it; ++it2) {
                    (*it2)->stop();
                }

                return err;
            }
        }
        return OK;
    }

然后调用每个Track的start方法

    status_t MPEG4Writer::Track::start(MetaData *params) {
        ...

        initTrackingProgressStatus(params);

        ...

        status_t err = mSource->start(meta.get()); // 这里会去执行CameraSource(start)，这两个是相互关联的

        ...

        pthread_create(&mThread, &attr, ThreadWrapper, this);
        return OK;
    }

    void *MPEG4Writer::Track::ThreadWrapper(void *me) {
        Track *track = static_cast<Track *>(me);

        status_t err = track->threadEntry();
        return (void *) err;
    }

通过status_t MPEG4Writer::Track::threadEntry()
是新启动另外一个thread，它里面会通过一个循环来不断读取CameraSource(read)里面的数据，CameraSource里面的数据当然是从driver返回过来的(可以参见CameraSourceListener，CameraSource用一个叫做mFrameReceived的List专门存放从driver过来的数据，如果收到数据会调用mFrameAvailableCondition.signal，若还没有开始录影，这个时候收到的数据是被丢弃的，当然MediaWriter先启动的是CameraSource的start方法，再启动写Track)，然后写到文件当中。
注意：准确来说这里MPEG4Writer读取的是OMXCodec里的数据，因为数据先到CameraSource，codec负责编码之后，MPEG4Writer才负责写到文件当中！关于数据在CameraSource/OMXCodec/MPEG4Writer之间是怎么传递的，可以参见http://guoh.org/lifelog/2013/06/interaction-between-stagefright-and-codec/当中讲Buffer的传输过程。

回头再来看，Stagefright做了什么事情？我更觉得它只是一个粘合剂(glue)的用处，它工作在MediaPlayerService这一层，把MediaSource，MediaWriter，Codec以及上层的MediaRecorder绑定在一起，这应该就是它最大的作用，Google用它来替换Opencore也是符合其一贯的工程派作风(相比复杂的学术派而言，虽然Google很多东西也很复杂，但是它一般都是以尽量简单的方式来解决问题)。
让大家觉得有点不习惯的是，它把MediaRecorder放在MediaPlayerService当中，这两个看起来是对立的事情，或者某一天它们会改名字，或者是两者分开，不知道～～

当然这只是个简单的大体介绍，Codec相关的后面争取专门来分析一下！

有些细节的东西在这里没有列出，需要的话会把一些注意点列出来：

1. 时光流逝录影
CameraSource对应的就是CameraSourceTimeLapse

具体做法就是在
dataCallbackTimestamp
当中有skipCurrentFrame

当然它是用些变量来记录和计算
mTimeBetweenTimeLapseVideoFramesUs(1E6/videoFrameRate) // 两个frame之间的间隔时间
记录上一个frame的(mLastTimeLapseFrameRealTimestampUs) // 上一个frame发生的时间
然后通过frame rate计算出两个frame之间的相距离时间，中间的都透过releaseOneRecordingFrame来drop掉
也就是说driver返回的东西都不变，只是在SW这层我们自己来处理掉

关于Time-lapse相关的可以参阅
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-lapse_photography

2. 录影当中需要用到Camera的话是通过ICameraRecordingProxy，即Camera当中的RecordingProxy(这是一个BnCameraRecordingProxy)
当透过binder，将ICameraRecordingProxy传到服务端进程之后，它就变成了Bp，如下：

case SET_CAMERA: {
    ALOGV("SET_CAMERA");
    CHECK_INTERFACE(IMediaRecorder, data, reply);
    sp<ICamera> camera = interface_cast<ICamera>(data.readStrongBinder());
    sp<ICameraRecordingProxy> proxy =
        interface_cast<ICameraRecordingProxy>(data.readStrongBinder());
    reply->writeInt32(setCamera(camera, proxy));
    return NO_ERROR;
} break;

在CameraSource当中会这样去使用

// We get the proxy from Camera, not ICamera. We need to get the proxy
// to the remote Camera owned by the application. Here mCamera is a
// local Camera object created by us. We cannot use the proxy from
// mCamera here.
mCamera = Camera::create(camera);
if (mCamera == 0) return -EBUSY;
mCameraRecordingProxy = proxy;
mCameraFlags |= FLAGS_HOT_CAMERA;

疑问点：

CameraSource当中这个
List > mFramesBeingEncoded;
有什么用？
每编码完一个frame，CameraSource就会将其保存起来，Buffer被release的时候，会反过来release掉这些frame(s)，这种做法是为了效率么？为什么不编码完一个frame就将其release掉？
另外不得不再感叹下Google经常的delete this;行为，精妙，但是看起来反常！